jump to navigation

Halal meat is more humane than factory meat April 2, 2012

Posted by hamiltonmuslims in News.
top-bg-left.png top-bg-top.png top-bg-right.png
March 31, 2012
CAIR-CAN Media Watch
Feature Article


Halal Meat is More Humane Than Factory Meat

By Ziyaad Mia, Vancouver Sun, March 28, 2012

As the Parti Quebecois conflates imagined Islamist plots with feigned concerns for animal welfare, I wonder if Chicken Little is on the separatist payroll. The latest act in Quebec’s Chronicles of Xenophobia takes us to the slaughterhouse, where the PQ claims all chickens are slaughtered under Islamic halal practice. The risk is twofold: (i) non-Muslim Quebecers will unwittingly eat halal meat; and (ii) halal slaughter practices are inhumane.

In response to the new-found problem, the PQ proposes a solution: clear labelling to protect the people of La Belle Province from halal meat. Interestingly, the solution only addresses the issue of unintentional consumption of halal meat, while being reticent on animal welfare. Moreover, because both the regulation of animal slaughter and food labelling are federal responsibilities, the solution is disingenuous.

Quebec politicians seem to be rip-ping pages from France’s playbook lately; first toying with hijab bans and now exposing the lurking threat of halal meat. They justify their actions by claiming that precious values are at stake. It is ironic that a province perennially clamouring for special treatment in our federal and constitutional family is quick to deny the distinctness of its own diverse communities. This is dangerous politics bereft of originality. Sadly, it is emblematic of a bankrupt social discourse that appears to be growing in Quebec.

With Canada facing significant challenges requiring positive solutions, the politicians of Quebec prefer the low road. While scapegoating Muslims is de rigueur among right-wingers, it seems that the left-leaning PQ is blazing a new trail by marching lockstep with the likes of Marine Le Pen, Nicolas Sarkozy, the Tea Party and Harper’s Conservatives.

Notwithstanding the PQ’s shameless exploitation of xenophobia, this controversy raises a genuine issue about the treatment of animals used for food, a matter that has largely been ignored in Canadian public discourse. In fact, it ought to be a serious ethical and moral concern for Muslim Canadians, in particular, because Islam requires significantly more than perfunctory ritualized killing of animals used for food. Islam mandates com-passionate treatment of all animals at all times, which precludes practices that are common in Canada’s factory farms and slaughterhouses. Hence, it poses the question whether much of the meat produced in Canada, including some "halal" meat, is consistent with the substance of Islam’s moral and ethical imperatives with respect to animals.

In North America billions of animals are raised annually in massive industrial operations, where they simply become living widgets. As a society we condone such cruelty because of our insatiable appetite for 99-cent break-fast sandwiches and burgers.

Consider chickens for example. In Canada we continue to allow the use of battery cages to raise birds for their eggs. Caged chickens are debeaked early in life; a practice that is intended to prevent pecking of other birds or self-harm such as plucking their own feathers. They do these things because they are extremely stressed, living in a cramped unnatural environment. It is fair to describe many battery chickens as literally going mad because they spend their entire lives confined to a tiny cage.

Canadians have cognitive dissonance when it comes to the creatures we eat. Eggs, meat and dairy products are pack-aged and marketed to remove any connection to the animals those products came from. As a result, we do not think about the plight of tens of millions of animals in an industrialized system designed to churn out cheap food.

Canada has inadequate laws for the protection of animals used in food production. Most, if not all, rules consider chickens and cows, like all animals, including our beloved cats and dogs, to be mere property. In absence of good legal standards that are robustly enforced we end up with a race to the bottom; volume and profit are the key drivers and animals are expendable production machines. While it may create short-term economic efficiencies, such a system puts us on morally unstable ground.

According to Mohandas Gandhi, "[t] he greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated." How do we measure up against that standard? If we want to be good citizens of a just nation, we cannot ignore the pain, stress and brutality suffered by animals to satisfy our desires. Contrary to the PQ’s aspersions, Islam goes much further than existing Canadian law by mandating compassion, rejecting the property model and requiring humans to give serious consideration to the interests of animals. That is why, on the issue of animal welfare, Muslim Canadians can lead by example.

Ziyaad Mia is a Toronto lawyer active in human rights, national security and animal welfare issues. He is a former board member of the Canadian Muslim Lawyers Association.

© Copyright (c) The Vancouver Sun


Verse Of The Week
Lost Indeed


Lost, indeed, are they who, in their weak-minded ignorance, slay their children and declare as forbidden that which God has provided for them as sustenance, falsely ascribing [such prohibitions] to God: they have gone astray and have not found the right path.

– Surah Al An’am, 6:140
[6th Chapter: The Cattle, Verse 140]


CALL TODAY TO DONATE AT 1.866.524.0004


P.O. Box 13219, Ottawa ON, K2K 1X4
T: 1.866.524.0004 F: 1.613.254.9810

DISCLAIMER: Views and/or assertions expressed by any material published in the Media Watch are solely those of their writer(s) and do not necessarily reflect those of the Board, employees or volunteers of CAIR-CAN. The Canadian Council on American-Islamic Relations is a federally incorporated, non-profit organization working to empower Canadian Muslims in the fields of the media, human rights, and public advocacy. Its board members include Kashif Ahmed, Dr. Jamal Badawi, Selma Djukic, Khalid Elgazzar, LL.B., Dr. Wael Haddara, Khadija Haffajee, Aftab Sabir and Shahina Siddiqui.
twitter.png facebook.png youtube.png

spacer.pngright-dotted-divide.pngspacer.png Help CAIR-CAN defend and empower Canadian Muslims


spacer.pngright-divid.pngspacer.png Upcoming Events


CAIR-CAN Gala feat. Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf


May 12, 2012 | 6:00pm
Park Hyatt Toronto
4 Avenue Road, Toronto
for more information…


CAIR-CAN in the News


United to Protect


Aftab Sabir,
CAIR-CAN Board Member
Calgary Herald, 03/28/12
read more…


Islamophobia: We need to accept the ‘other’


Karen Armstrong,
Globe and Mail, 03/26/12
read more…


News & Views


Omar Khadr’s transfer to Canada nears approval


CBC, 03/28/12
read more…


Halal meat is more humane than factory meatdelete.png

Ziad Mia,
Ottawa Citizen, 03/28/12read more…


Some Muslims claim discrimination over hijab


Fay al-Hakim,
Ottawa Citizen, 03/28/12
read more…


Little Mosque on the Prairie: concept was bigger than the show


Toronto Star, 03/24/12
read more…


Why you shouldn’t tell American border guards you’re in Islamic Studies


Andreanne Stewart,
McGill Daily, 03/26/12
read more…


Book tells Muslim men how to beat and control their wives


Terry Davidson,
Toronto Sun, 03/23/12
read more…


Social media role in police cases growing


Roger Yu,
Toronto Star, 03/25/12
read more…


10 Muslim women every person should know


Fazeela Siddiqui,
Huffington Post, 03/25/12
read more…


footer-left.pngspacer.pngYou are subscribed
Easy Unsubscribe | My Settings | Forward This E-mail
P.O. Box 13219
Ottawa, ON K2K1X4




No comments yet — be the first.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: